Occasionally, the game presents genuinely inventive multi-step puzzles that require players to synthesise clues from various locations, leading to gratifying “aha” moments when everything falls into place. Unfortunately, these more complex puzzles are often followed by simpler tasks that can feel underdeveloped or overly dependent on obscure logic. While there are times when progression feels fluid and engaging, other moments can leave players aimlessly exploring after overlooking a minor detail or misinterpreting vague hints. This uneven pacing can disrupt the otherwise captivating flow of exploration.

The introduction of dual protagonists alters the gameplay dynamics, allowing players to leverage each character’s unique perspective and knowledge in creative ways. Although this mechanic doesn’t develop into something particularly intricate, it effectively enhances the pacing and provides a more expansive feel compared to its predecessor. The exploration remains visually captivating, with each setting showcasing stunning architecture, cosmic visuals, and atmospheric nuances that invite players to engage deeply with their surroundings.

Despite some inconsistencies, Call of the Elder Gods generally excels in its gameplay. The standout puzzles leave a lasting impression, the exploration is deeply engaging, and the overall atmosphere helps to elevate weaker moments, even when the challenge levels vary. Players seeking a laid-back narrative puzzle experience infused with strong Lovecraftian elements are likely to find enjoyment here, though those anticipating consistently refined puzzle design may be deterred by the fluctuating difficulty and occasional ambiguity, which could prevent the game from reaching its full potential.